| Rev. John Arogyasami | 2018-Present | Interior Renovation of St. Mary’s Church |
| Rev. Mark Noonan | 2010-2018 | St. Mary 150th Anniversary Successful Capital Campaign for Parish Improvements |
| Rev. Joseph Kozlowski | 1992-2010 | Heritage Campaign to Fund Needed Repairs |
| Rev. Charles E. Slisz | 1985-1992 | Major Church Renovations, Closed School in 1990 |
| Rev. James D. Walker | 1981-1985 | Feasibility Study to Keep School Open |
| Rev. William Honor | 1980-1981 | |
| Rev. Thomas L. Kemp | 1976-1980 | Started the St. Rocco’s Festival |
| Rev. Joseph J. Weber | 1964-1976 | St. Mary’s 100th Anniversary |
| Rev. Robert Howard | 1946-1964 | Built St. Mary’s School, Paved Road to the Cemetery |
| Rev. Felix McCabe | 1938-1946 | Erected Grotto of Our Lady of Lourdes |
| Rev. Richard T. Burke | 1912-1937 | Parish Debt Cleared, Cemetery Enlarged, Celebrated 60 Years as a Priest |
| Rev. James McCarthy | 1902-1912 | St. Mary’s Church was Built, New Rectory was Built (Dedicated Dec. 24, 1905) |
| Rev. Michael Noon | 1898-1902 | Main Street Land Purchased |
| Rev. James Leddy | 1888-1898 | Parish Incorporated Under NYS Law |
| Rev. Patrick Maloy | 1881-1888 | Attorney |
| Rev. James Lasher | 1876-1881 | Rectory Built, Cemetery Added |
| Rev. David Lasher | 1875-1876 | First Resident Pastor |
| Rev. John Castaldi | 1873-1875 | St. Mary’s of the Assumption Dedicated to Our Blessed Mother |